I have been converting Mutable Instruments Eagle board files to Kicad. The process is pretty easy and I will publish everything on Github once I am complete. I am going to fabricate some boards from the new Kicad files as a test to see if they are good.
I am going to make a Shruthi and Shruthi XT with a couple of filter boards, and then probably make rings, stages, and elements.
But I am curious if anyone has already done this. If no one has done it I’ll make sure to do a more thorough job. Otherwise if the task has already been done I won’t worry about publishing a duplicate.
I just started learning about synthesizers and I am in love with these products. I am so happy Emilie has made this all open source! I started my own electronics company on Kickstarter in 2013 but failed to manage it all myself, so I am very impressed with what she has done.
Recently I built a Shruthi from scratch using my Kicad conversion files. It works great! So I am working on a How-To video for the kicad conversion process, and I will be releasing the open source files with the video soon. I will update when that is up but I did post some of my footage in a tweet here if anyone wants to see it:
I see. Edif is for netlists only. This github project does more, with less certainty. And a lot of caveats.
Fwiw, U used to do netlist conversion with emacs keyboard macros. You can recreate the PCB stack up by hand. It’s not a lot of work that can’t be hand entered again. Copying the layout of this size is manageable.
In my experience, it’s easier to do a design of this size by hand. Then you will know exactly what’s there. With conversions, you don’t know the tools, or the design, you can’t check the output with any certainty.
Unless there’s a foolproof way - personally, I would do it by hand. You’ll learn something from it as well. But that’s just me.
Interesting. As a check, I overlaid the gerber files generated by Eagle with the gerber files generated by Kicad with difference highlighting. That was very helpful. And then of course building them is a great test.
When you say “recreate the PCB stack up by hand” do you mean place all of the components and route the board? In the end my goal is a fully editable Kicad project.
Interesting. Well it seems I am able to accurately convert the boards in a few minutes with this tool. I’d not want to re-lay them out as even with the design rules it would be a lot of work. In the future I plan to convert the eurorack modules to Kicad as well (actually I have already been doing this) and I will also fabricate them to test them. So I’ll have a whole synth setup of self-made stuff.
See, your itch is reverse engineering and mine is fabricating stuff!
Kicad has a fairly straightforward built-in tool for conversion. You don’t need to rely on someone else to do it for you. Make sure you check the layers used in Eagle to use as a reference to check if Kicad pulled all the layers in Eagle into the right ones in Kicad.
First step seems to be to open the board and schematics from Émilie’s GitHub with an Eagle version 6 or higher, as in the current state (at least the one I tried to import, Shelves) KiCad cannot read them.
Then save them again, without doing anything.
Then KiCad will want to import. I did the automatic mapping of layers of the board at first and that looks good, but will maybe compare them side by side again to double check.
The schematics I did not get across yet. There is an error. I will try again and write down which error.